‘Resistance to change’ is the action taken by individuals and groups when they perceive that a change that is occurring as a threat to them.

Discussions within the shipping industry on disintermediation, incorporating automation and technology are growing and getting louder, and even louder are the knee-jerk reactions of traditionalists who remind you that it’s a relationship-based business and that a robotic touch can never feel as good as a human touch.

The purpose of this blog is not to merely talk about more of the same, but rather dwell a little deeper into this phenomenon called ‘Resistance to change’. A lot of the technology required to automate systems and processes in the shipping industry is already available and has been for many years now.

The maritime industry and the broader ocean supply chain, especially in the dry bulk and tanker sector are suffering from major and costly inefficiencies which arise out of ineffective data sharing and poor cross-industry collaboration. If that were not enough, factors such as gross overcapacity, severely depressed freight rates, fragmentation and lack of financing means the industry should want to embrace technology and embrace changes in the way things could be done, and the way it is possible to get things done with automation and the latest technology.

But why has the shipping industry so far lagged behind in embracing automation? Could be many things but the needle tilts to the following in my opinion…

The loosely defined ocean shipping industry which includes ship owners, brokers, agents and other stakeholders is an old one -, traditional, conservative and historically known to have been resistant to change. People and corporations are bound to resist change when they perceive it as a threat. The operative keywords here are ‘perceive’ and ‘threat’. This threat need not be real or large for resistance to occur. The obvious ‘threat’ in this case is people losing their jobs, companies losing their relevance or their roles being marginalized. And we’re not only talking about entry-level workers or low-wage clerks who collect and process data whose jobs will be on the line, but a more macro level consolidation in organizational structures even with ‘high-paying-jobs’.

If the healthcare and banking industries are one of the first to adopt the use of automation, the efficiencies
stemming from it have also resulted in thousands of employees losing their jobs. Ocean shipping and its related supply chain is probably one of the last industries to embrace automation and digitization, and people in commercial shipping should feel relatively safe about their jobs, because right now resistance is winning over the change.

The question that we should really ask is, why has disintermediation not fully been accepted and adopted by the industry on a full scale although a few attempts are being made.

In my opinion, the Resistance can only broken by forces from outside the shipping and supply chain industry. We are already seeing this in the container liner trade, where Alibaba and Amazon have done away with freight forwarders, assumed the role of ship brokers and are increasing their involvement in the supply chain. Intermediaries and brokers will always have a place in the shipping and supply chain industry, although these intermediaries will soon lose their human form and be replaced by online platforms.

Ennero has received a prestigious award in recognition of our…

Ennero is honoured to have been recognized by Enoc with a prestigious award for our exceptional 170...

See More

A glance into our Marine Lubricants operations in Cape Town

Ennero SA delivers on its promise to service its clients with ENOC marine lubricants across all Sou...

See More

Inside Ennero South Africa: Energizing a New Day

Operating out of our corporate office in Johannesburg, Ennero SA’s footprint across South Africa ...

See More

Introducing Ennero – A glimpse into our daily activities

At Ennero, we pride ourselves in delivering service excellence to our clients. We are a leading tra...

See More

Ennero held a drag race event in collaboration with Enoc…

Ennero held another very successful event in collaboration with Enoc Marine at the Dubai Autodrome....

See More

Ennero held their very first successful event in collaboration with…

Ennero held their very first event in collaboration with Enoc at the Dubai Autodrome. They gathered...

See More

Ennero has been awarded a recognition trophee from Enoc for…

Ennero has been awarded a recognition trophee from Enoc for an outstanding marine lubricant sales a...

See More

Ennero has been awarded a recognition certificate for an outstanding…

Enoc has awarded a recognition certificate to Ennero for an outstanding performance in the marine l...

See More

Enoc Group appoints Ennero to expand international footprint in marine…

Enoc aims to grow the sales of its marine lubricant’s portfolio to bolster its international pres...

See More

Contending With A World Of Scarce Resources

The latest forward curve shows Diesel being steadily backwardated in the prompt with demand strong ...

See More

5 Minutes With Jawad Nizar

What is Ennero’s core business activity? Ennero is an oil trading firm, based out of Dubai and...

See More

New Hire Vuyo-Matshaya

Following up on our recent announcement regarding the establishment of our South African subsidiary...

See More

New Regional Offices Launched

The Ennero Group is pleased to announce the establishment of Ennero SA Pty Ltd., a corporate subsid...

See More

The Diesel Dilemna

Shipping Market Briefs Lorem Ipsum is simply dummy text of the printing and typesetting industry. ...

See More

Resistance To Change

‘Resistance to change’ is the action taken by individuals and groups when they perceive that a ...

See More

The New Kings of Oil Finance

The Financial Times concluded that once upon a time Morgan Stanley, one of the original “wall str...

See More